Row triangle Shape Decorative svg added to top

Which Jobs Should Get the Shop’s Last Open Hours?

If your manufacturing client has more work available than the shop can finish, the owner may want to give the biggest jobs the remaining space on the schedule. Each one leaves more money after its direct costs, so the choice can look settled before you open the books.

“Shouldn’t we take the job that makes us more?”

Ask what the owner wants from the next production period. More contribution to overhead may be the priority, while promised delivery dates still have to hold. Then ask which step is running out of time.

A large job could occupy the finishing station for most of a day. Several smaller jobs might use the same hours and leave more money between them, provided customers actually want them and the rest of the shop can keep up.

Before recommending more equipment or another shift, help the owner compare what those scarce hours can produce. Keep work already promised to customers in place. The decision concerns the hours still available to offer, not permission to break a commitment because another order looks better.

A fuller schedule deserves a closer look

The New York Fed’s November 16 manufacturing survey reported rising unfilled orders and a longer average workweek among responding New York State manufacturers. Capital spending plans also strengthened. Responses were collected November 2 through November 9; this regional survey doesn’t establish conditions at your client’s shop.

The obvious response to a growing queue is to add capacity. Before pricing that response, check whether the current schedule makes good use of the capacity that is actually scarce.

Start with the FIX Framework. Find the Burning Issue by agreeing on the owner’s goal: improve the money the existing shop earns without missing customer promises. That puts profitability at the center, with operations providing the evidence.

Identify the Fuel Source by following recent jobs through the floor. Ask the supervisor where work waits, then compare that answer with job records and completed shipments. A machine that looks busy may still spend hours waiting for materials or redoing work.

Clear Path To Cash’s Process Optimizer is described as a way to map and improve workflows. Use that process view to locate the limiting step before comparing job costs. The advisor still needs the supervisor to validate usable hours, including setup, rework and downtime.

If the real problem is missing orders rather than a full work center, this comparison won’t fix it. That calls for a different demand-versus-throughput investigation.

Compare the money earned by the scarce hour

Suppose the next period has 40 finishing hours still uncommitted. Customers could confirm up to six large jobs and eight smaller ones for that period, and every job must pass through finishing.

A large job sells for $2,500 and requires $1,600 of costs that change when the shop accepts it. That leaves $900 of contribution before unchanged overhead. It needs six finishing hours, including setup.

A smaller job sells for $1,800, has $1,100 of those costs, and leaves $700. It needs two finishing hours.

Check those costs against actual records. Include additional labor when it changes with the order, but don’t subtract the same unchanged payroll again. Allow for waste, fees and outside work where they apply.

The large job leaves more per job. Divide its $900 contribution by six finishing hours, though, and it produces $150 per scarce hour. The smaller job produces $350 per finishing hour: $700 divided by two.

Six large jobs and two smaller ones would fill all 40 hours and leave $6,800 toward unchanged overhead. Four large jobs and eight smaller ones would also fill 40 hours, leaving $9,200.

That’s a $2,400 difference between two uses of the same finishing time. It is a planning comparison under these assumptions, not a result the shop has achieved.

Don’t fill the calendar with unlimited smaller jobs. This example has demand for only eight, and customer acceptance still needs confirmation. The next work center must also be able to handle the selected mix.

Turn the comparison into a recommendation

Use the costing side of Clear Path To Cash to organize the economics, then connect it to the process evidence. The useful output is a supported recommendation about the schedule; software cannot establish that customers will order or that an operator can meet a cycle time.

Ask the production lead to check both mixes against materials and the delivery calendar. Include inspection and packing. Improving finishing output won’t help if completed work then waits somewhere else.

If the checks hold, recommend offering the four-large, eight-small mix for the next uncommitted period before buying more capacity. The expected benefit is $2,400 more contribution than the comparison mix, without adding finishing hours. The owner decides whether that financial benefit fits customer relationships and longer-term priorities.

Keep contribution separate from cash. Some materials may already be paid for, others require a deposit, and customers may pay after delivery. Put the actual receipts and additional payments on their dates before describing the contribution gain as spendable money.

If extra capacity is still needed, take the verified workload into the equipment financing cash plan. That is a later decision about carrying the investment until collections arrive.

Give the scheduler responsibility for obtaining customer confirmation before reserving the open hours. The production lead records actual finishing time, and the bookkeeper checks realized revenue and changing costs. The advisor reviews the comparison at the end of the production period.

Review what the schedule actually delivered

Record the baseline and expected result in the action plan before the owner acts. Clear Path To Cash Advisor’s documented Action Log supports assigned tasks and target-versus-actual impact, so the recommendation can return to the next meeting with evidence attached.

Compare actual contribution with the $9,200 expectation and finishing time with the 40-hour limit. Review missed deliveries and rework too. A higher planned contribution is poor evidence of success if the shop misses an important customer promise.

Reopen the recommendation if customer demand changes, the smaller jobs take longer than expected, or another step becomes the limit. The best mix depends on the conditions you verified, and those conditions can move.

Return to the owner’s question about taking the job that makes more. Ask the owner to compare the whole available schedule before choosing.

A job earns its place by what it contributes through the hours the shop can’t replace.

Clear Path To Cash Advisor helps financial professionals apply this discipline: investigate the client’s issue, form a recommendation and follow the result. The advisor checks the evidence and leads the conversation; the owner chooses the work.

Try the AI-powered Clear Path to Cash® 7-Day Free Trial.

clearpathrocashlogob1b925ea0d83a0dadc8b

Start a 7-Day Free Trial of the AI-powered Clear Path to Cash® system, preloaded with a sample company so you can explore how it works in real advisory moments.

 

No credit card.
No setup.
No sales pitch.

 

Just hands-on access to the system advisors use when clients are waiting for direction.

mike sig blue

Mike Milan
Founder, Cash Flow Mike