The Crew Did the Extra Work. Can You Bill It?
If a customer asks an electrical crew to add a few outlets while they’re already on site, the owner may want to keep the job moving. The tools are out, the customer is pleased, and stopping to discuss paperwork could feel like making a small request difficult.
By the time the bookkeeper reviews the job, the crew may have completed the extra work. Their hours are on the time sheets, and the materials have left the stockroom.
The owner might ask, “Can’t we just add it to the final invoice?” Before anyone does that, the advisor needs to know what the customer actually approved.
Perhaps the customer approved the work without discussing a price. Perhaps the person who asked for it couldn’t authorize additional spending, or the signed agreement requires a separate approval before an extra charge can be billed.
Each situation leaves the business with a different collection problem. Payroll still has a payment date, even when the right to bill is unresolved.
Before the crew accepts the next request, the owner needs a workable rule for deciding which changes can proceed and how the business will carry their cost.
Look behind the pressure to raise prices
The October NFIB survey, covered by Haver Analytics on November 10, showed a net 33% of firms raising selling prices while the earnings-trend measure fell to a net negative 23%. That earnings reading is a survey balance, not a 23% decline in business profits.
NFIB surveys its members, so these responses don’t establish what caused a particular company’s earnings to weaken. They certainly don’t tell an electrical shop whether a customer’s extra request is billable.
The obvious response to weaker earnings is to review pricing. That’s worth doing, but a higher hourly rate won’t collect money for work the customer never agreed to buy.
An advisor should inspect the path from the customer’s request to the invoice. Where did the description of the extra work go, who accepted the price, and what record allows the office to bill it?
Start with a few recently completed jobs. Compare the original scope with crew notes and time sheets, then match the differences to approved changes and actual invoices.
Separate work included in the original price from additional requests. Correcting the company’s own mistake may be warranty work or rework; calling it an extra doesn’t make the customer responsible for paying.
Find out what can actually be collected
For each genuine scope change, ask the owner to locate the customer’s authorization. Check the agreed price and any billing requirements in the contract before treating the amount as collectible.
Some work may be approved and ready to invoice. Other work may require an explanation, supporting documents, or a conversation with someone who can authorize the expense.
Keep disputed or unapproved amounts out of supported cash receipts until the uncertainty is resolved. Issuing an invoice alone doesn’t settle the customer’s obligation or establish a dependable payment date.
The advisor’s role is to expose the financial consequence. Questions about contractual rights or enforcement belong with qualified legal help when needed.
Now examine the cost of the extra work. Include materials already used and additional paid hours, while distinguishing costs already incurred from payments that can still be avoided.
If the crew is on regular payroll either way, declining one request won’t automatically save those wages. The request may instead consume hours needed to finish another billable job, which deserves a separate look at the schedule.
Make the handoff usable for a person standing on a job site. The crew needs to know who can authorize a change and where to send the request before work continues.
The office then needs enough detail to connect the approval to the invoice. A missing attachment should have a named person responsible for resolving it.
Put the approval beside the payment dates
For the next proposed change, use current estimates rather than trying to recover yesterday’s costs through a new decision. The question is whether accepting more work produces enough cash, soon enough, to justify the commitment.
Suppose a change would require 18 additional paid hours at a cash labor cost of $50 per hour, including applicable employment costs. Materials would require another $600 payment, making the additional cash outflow $1,500.
If the customer agrees to a $2,400 price, the change leaves $900 before other overhead and taxes. That calculation assumes the stated costs capture the additional work; it isn’t the company’s net profit.
Now put the dates into a 13-week cash forecast. If the $1,500 leaves in week two and the customer pays in week five, the business carries the full cost for that interval.
If the existing forecast leaves only $800 above the owner’s minimum cash floor in week two, accepting the change puts it $700 below that floor. The eventual $900 surplus won’t solve the earlier shortage.
A separately agreed $1,200 advance, received before those payments, would leave $500 above the floor instead. The remaining $1,200 would be due later under the agreed terms, not counted again as a full $2,400 receipt.
Give the crew a rule the office can support
The owner may choose to request an advance, move the extra work to a later date, or decline it. Each option depends on the customer relationship, the agreement and the operating commitments already in place.
Test a delayed receipt as well. If the advance doesn’t arrive before the crew is due to start, the forecast should show that gap and the owner should decide whether work waits.
Set a clear approval boundary for future requests. A crew member can document what the customer wants without committing the business to an unpriced change.
For work already completed, assign someone to resolve each missing approval and track the outcome. Review what was accepted, what was billed and what actually reached the bank.
At the next advisor meeting, compare the expected collection dates with the receipts. If extras keep sitting unresolved, repair that handoff before assuming another price increase will improve cash.
Return to the owner’s question about adding the outlets to the final invoice. The answer starts with the scope and authorization, followed by a payment date the business can support.
Every extra hour needs an answer to who will pay for it.
Clear Path To Cash Advisor gives advisors a system for applying this judgment: diagnose the issue, examine its cause, compare practical actions and model the cash impact with the owner. The advisor checks the evidence and helps the client choose what happens next.
Try the AI-powered Clear Path to Cash® 7-Day Free Trial.
Start a 7-Day Free Trial of the AI-powered Clear Path to Cash® system, preloaded with a sample company so you can explore how it works in real advisory moments.
No credit card.
No setup.
No sales pitch.
Just hands-on access to the system advisors use when clients are waiting for direction.
Mike Milan
Founder, Cash Flow Mike